Friday, 25 October 2013

Do I need to get a home tutor?


One of the most frequent questions asked at parents' evenings these days is should I get her a tutor? 

Although I believe that suitably qualified tutors can be helpful for children with specific learning differences and difficulties, usually within the school or guided by the class teacher rather than externally, I have become concerned about the prevalence of engaging ‘academic’ tutors as a matter of course. I have known some teachers who I'm sure would be wonderful tutors, but others who have not been high achieving or successful in the classroom and would not be offering your child excellence or giving you value for money. 

One to one tuition at home, according to recent reports in the media, is as common as attending school. There are now more people offering private tuition than there are teachers in schools. None of these need to be qualified or to conform to reasonable standards. Having a Mrs Doubtfire demeanour, or a track record as a tutor for many years is not necessarily good enough. Companies exist to offer tuition at particular stages in the school career, to assist with 11+ entry, to prepare for public examinations, or just to top up what is being done at school. Many of these cannot guarantee results and an analysis of their success rates, for example in grammar school entry, correlate to the child's natural ability and the amount of rigorous rehearsal (which they can do with you or by themselves using resources bought from WHSmiths) rather than something magical these tutors have added in the many hours of paid extra. I have been frustrated by parents wondering why their children are making poor progress towards independent learning, when most of their child’s ‘individual’ learning is coached by someone sitting beside them. Whilst tuition can work for some, it is certainly not a panacea for academic improvement. 

It is worth remembering that tuition may actually be counterproductive: 

  • Children who regularly work alongside a tutor soon learn that there is no expectation that they can, or should, manage independently. 
  • Children used to tuition have a fear of getting things wrong and become reliant on instant praise, feedback, correction and support – failing to develop the resilience that is essential for effective learning. 
  • Children who have intensive coaching for examinations often feel de-skilled and deeply demoralised if the tuition has simply raised them to an academic environment, set or school where they cannot really manage by themselves. 
  • Tutors have no regulation: they may be wonderful, but there is no control over what they teach, how current their knowledge might be, or how effectively they work with children. 
  • Ex-teachers may not be up to date with ever changing methods and syllabuses and can confuse their tutees, or give them conflicting methods or information to worry about. 
  • Tutors are unlikely to have the same view of progression and continuity that the class or subject teachers have, because at school the teaching team will be working together to create something coherent in terms of learning strategies, linked knowledge and experience across the curriculum. 
  • Home tutors will not be working from the plans for the year at school, and may worry you or your child about gaps and aspects of the syllabus that have simply not been covered yet for very sound reasons. 
  • Tutors offering individual lessons often overstate or at least overestimate the ability of your child, who may cope extremely well in one to one sessions, but not necessarily in a classroom, or when later expected to work independently or under exam conditions. The confidence that a child shows the tutor due to close questioning, lots of praise, strong educational scaffolding and a coaching relationship is very different from the expectations of the school or during assessment. 
  • Most worryingly, there are no safeguarding guarantees about an unregulated and unchecked person in your home. 

My advice as a Head Teacher is to use tuition only when advised to by the school: for supporting strategies for learning, for managing learning difficulties or in the short term for keeping the brain awake over long holidays. Make sure you have up to date references for anyone you invite into your home, and check on the qualifications and experience of the tutor. Grand results regarding other children are not helpful – that child may have a completely different set of abilities, skills and needs from your own. Tell the school if you have engaged a tutor, the most fruitful experiences will be those that mirror and complement the school curriculum. Visit the session each time to see what is happening, and if your child is overwhelmed, confused, tired or becoming reliant on too much ‘tuition’, support, praise or encouragement, then stop the lessons, they are simply not helping. 

Children who are doing perfectly well at school do not need to be discouraged by having extra work in their free time, nor another adult questioning their ability, impeding their ability to develop independent strategies and pressuring them over their results. 

A parent I have known for many years spoke to me last week about her reason for stopping tuition after eighteen months with a very nice tutor. She said that she popped in on a session to discover, not for the first time, that the tutor was simply helping with the homework the class teacher had set and already prepared, no more, and no less - for £45. She said she felt pressured into organising tuition because all her friends had a tutor for their children. I asked if she had booked the lessons so that her child could have different work, more help or just more practice, but she said she had left it all in the hands of the tutor who was well qualified and came highly recommended. She said had not informed the school because she didn’t want us to think her daughter was getting help. She said that she had just come to the realisation that her child was actually doing fine, and that she was no longer going to worry about the extra mark or two the tutor could wring from the piece of work. I applaud, and I hope that the saved money is used for a really enjoyable family activity. 

Education is a holistic thing. Would your child benefit from a tutor? Probably not as much as she would benefit from you reading to her each evening if she is young, or taking her on a weekly trip to the library, or for older pupils taking the time to discuss coursework, promoting rational argument at the dinner table and engendering an interest in current affairs. 

Friday, 11 October 2013

What did she get in the test?

In our lives today we are all subject to review and audit. It has become so much part of our culture that what we used to think of as our daily work has become something under endless scrutiny, and rather than allowing for inspiration, creativity, rehearsal, formation thinking, practising and self-improvement, we seem to be obsessed with attainment test results, and have forgotten that learning is a process and not simply a one off packaged ‘result’.

So, unfortunately, much of we do becomes an instant measure of our self-worth. My own mother, undertaking a Diploma in Botanical Art for the Royal Society, in her mid-seventies, was very upset when her 8.4 grade average dropped to 7.9 due to a ‘badly’ coloured leaf. “The tutor liked the leaf shape,” she told me, “But the depth of colour was not right in the leaf veins”. When I pointed out that 7.9 was 79% and probably an A grade she was surprised. Nonetheless she was ready to go on to do battle with herself in the next assignment, despite not having practised or had a chance to get the leaf right – because she thought she had to go on to the next thing, and try to get that right in one bash too.

For me, education should not be like this, I believe it is a long and thoughtful process. Yes, educationalists have talked for a long time about building blocks that found and build learning, but that must not be understood as each piece of knowledge being a brick in a wall in its own right. Most of knowledge, skill and discerned understanding comes in a web or network of interconnected ideas. It takes time to season. Given that education in school takes place over at least thirteen years, there is some time for a well educated child to benefit from a gradual unfolding of the world of knowledge. It is well proven that early or rapid success is not the best precursor to lifelong achievement: look at Einstein, Mo Farrah or Churchill!

At my primary aged school, we have embarked on a holistic programme of giving the girls an opportunity each week to work independently at a task, under the sort of conditions she would face in a test, but with the work that she is doing in class. We believe this has a number of purposes. The first is Formative, where we can see what the child can do unaided, where she needs support or scaffolding, where she can think for herself, where she can practise the little aspects of setting out she has been shown such as where to put titles and date if not instructed. The second is Ipsitive where the child sees how she has done over time, and is able to make a pattern of her progress, comparing not just results, but also how she copes with the experience. The teacher can create a pattern to see what is developing and what needs help. This is not a comparison with others, but a proper examination of the development of the child over time, by concentrating on her progress in relation to her ability and her journey. The third is Meta-cognitive where a child comes to understand for herself how she learns best, what helps her when she is learning and what she needs to remember. It is the often unnoticed part of the process, where children become aware of their own ability, their own strengths and the things they can do for and by themselves that make things go right when they do them, and wrong when they don’t. Each child soon gets the hang of how this feels, and is encouraged to look through the work to see what she could have done, herself, to do better this time, or for next time.

This activity is not designed to be Summative however. It is not a close of play event such as GCSE or A level, it is not used in the way an entrance test or formal exam might be. It is not used as a measure of success, although success is valued, alongside good progress. It is not a test to check up what was learnt before moving on.

My belief is that excellent teaching and learning must include this space for children to rehearse, to come to an understanding about their work, to begin and then to become skilled at managing on their own. If these opportunities are not presented young, and repeated regularly then real learning, real depth of knowledge, effective skills, creativity, self-esteem, confidence, resilience and inspiration will not develop. Tests certainly have their place, at end of term or year, between phases and as rites of passage. They are a useful measure for the outside world or for parents of what has been achieved in a reasonable space of time. But in between times I believe children should be allowed to learn from having a go, free from the fear of their own results.

Wednesday, 25 September 2013

What are the rights of your child?

Childhood might be a time when children have an inalienable right to have fun, to be carefree, to be supported regardless of what they do or say, to get away now and again with avoiding doing what they are told, to be allowed the freedom to develop independence, to have you fight their battles for them, to have showered upon them the things that you may not have had in your childhood. 

I am a great believer in the universal rights of the child, and of a proper happy childhood, but here is my bill of additional rights that I believe educators and parents should also bear in mind:

·        The right to a good night’s sleep – so yes, make them go to bed at whatever time this needs to be to stop yawning and confusion.
·        The right to be prepared for the next day at school – so help them sort their things out before bed and go through with them what might be happening and what they might need to have packed.
·        The right to understand that their actions have consequences, not next time, but this time – and a discussion to help them understand what to do next time, and not just a punishment that creates resentment.
·        The right to learn to work hard, in order to achieve what they are capable of, but without the handicap of excuses that hinder their progress rather than help.
·        The right to be rewarded for the good things they do and say, but not too generously - some of these things they should be doing anyway. Helping at home and displaying good manners shouldn't require payment!
·        The right to hear "yes", when their requests are reasonable and the right to hear "no" when they are not, to help them to make sense of their place in the world.
·        The right to become increasingly responsible for the things in their lives; with your support and with appropriate age related scaffolding.
·        The right to have another go, have a fresh start and to be given the benefit of the doubt. Going over old negative ground can set up a pattern of undesireable behavour rather than changing them.
·        The right to be listened to 'with a pinch of salt', to help children to understand that their versions of the truth may not be the most accurate perspective on an event.

These rights may seem counterintuitive in some ways they don’t represent the easiest course of action in a busy day, and they will need to be part of a consistent approach. But they will help each child to realise that she is one among many, that she has amazing potential, but that her gifts and talents will be wasted if she is not able to use them well and wisely.

The school and the home, together, should enable each child to learn to hold her own, to have friends, to be happy, to start to take responsibility for her own independent self and for her work.

The great news is that the educational process is not a quick fix, and therefore there are many years to work towards the perfect adult we would like each child to be. It is like making sourdough bread, or fine wine, it takes time, it takes expertise and it takes effort on the part of us all, including your children.

To hear more about this, within the context of my own school please click on the video link below to hear me speaking to parents at a welcome evening.


Thursday, 4 July 2013

Moving On

This week I made an address at the Ceremony of Achievement that marks the last days of our Year 6 girls as they leave for their Senior Schools. Several people asked me if I could put it here on my blog site to be re-read:

“I am sure many of you have read Harry Potter, or seen the films and remember the mirror of Erised. This mirror doesn’t show what is standing in front of it, nor does it show in some magic way what the future will hold, or who is the fairest of them all, this mirror just shows what is desired most by the person looking in.

Professor Dumbledore warns Harry, that lives are wasted by staring into a future that is based on desire for what that person just wants. These are wise words, not because we shouldn’t desire good things, or want to offer the best of ourselves in life, but because we would be fools to think that life will open its doors and happiness and riches to us just because we want it to.

All of you in our leaving class have many God given talents and gifts. We have celebrated some of these this morning, but many of you can only glimpse at what you might achieve in later life, what might become ‘your thing’, or what you may come to love. Some of you, with your limited experience of life will not have any idea of what wonders are to come, or what you could achieve. I spend much of my free time singing with choirs or composing music, but had no idea I could sing until I was 29 years old!

I know that most of you will have watched those Saturday night programmes where people with not much talent beg to be allowed one more chance to become famous … because they really REALLY want it, or because it was a dying grandmother’s greatest wish. If you model your life on something that does not take account of what you can do, backed up by hard work, by finding your way, and by gently and happily allowing life to unfold around you each day, with all of the joys and terrors that can bring, then you may never find yourself or the happiness you deserve. You may find yourself staring into that mirror of desire and wondering what happened.

So here is my parting advice to you as Head Teacher:

·         Make a friend by being a friend.
·         Remember what it might be like to be someone else’s shoes and don’t lose sight of the fact that they are a person with feelings just like you
·         Do what you say you will do – be honest, have integrity.
·         Don’t give up too easily – success is rarely instant.
·         Don’t wait for opportunities to be created for you – make them yourself. (I am friends with a world class organist who was turned down lessons with one of the best teachers. So he turned pages for the organist in the local church and built his great success by helping someone else, in the right place at the right time.)
·         Follow your plans and your talents not just your dreams. Be realistic, hardworking and smart, and never think that life comes to you while you sleep.
·         Lastly, always in the tradition of St Jeanne remember to stretch out a hand to others, as it is in giving to others that we ourselves are made whole and wonderful people

Girls, I do hope you have been happy in your earliest years at Notre Dame School. You have each of you been a credit to us and to your families. I pray that this continues wherever you go, near or far and that you always remember the friends, teachers, Sisters and community that brought you to this place, ready to jump off  into the world of the big school.

Parents, Godparents and friends, I thank you for all you do for these lucky girls, and trust that with your support and guidance they will find that some of their dreams are able to be realised not just through good fortune and chance but through their own efforts and determination to build on the firm foundations they have developed here at Notre Dame School and in your homes. I know you want the best for these children and that you want them to be the best they can be – let them guide you too and allow them to become the person God intended, to become who they truly are.”

Thursday, 13 June 2013

Why is learning a musical instrument good for the brain?

Today’s blog was written as a report for me by Julie Shaw, Head of Music in the Prep section at Notre Dame School, and it is so good I thought I would share it with you all.
At this time of the year at Notre Dame School a wonderful little crop of afternoon Soirees and Lunchtime concerts is harvested from amongst the instrumentalists and singers in the Prep School who have been working hard all year with their individual teachers and at home practising to develop their musical skills.  It is wonderful to see these pupils flourishing and gaining confidence as they perform solos to their parents and peers – children as young as Year 1 right up to Year 6 standing up in public and really showing what they are made of.  As they take their bow at the end of their piece, flushed and proud to receive their applause, all those hard hours and minutes of practising seem worthwhile.
Much has been made in the press of the so-called ‘Mozart Effect’ – the effect on intelligence and on core subject skills such as literacy and numeracy of children learning an instrument or playing in an ensemble.  Some claims are high flown and geared towards parting caring parents with their cash – there are for example CD players on the market fitted with special speakers to play Mozart to the unborn child in the womb.  Amidst all the other activities available to enhance your child’s progress, this is another one fighting for your money and your child’s time.  So what research is there to support these claims? 
Many studies have reported positive associations between music education and increased abilities in non-musical (e.g. linguistic, mathematical, and spatial) domains in children and here we have only room for a few examples.  Studies have been carried out in Canada, where - in one case - researchers found musically trained children (aged four to six) performed better in memory tests than those who had no instrument lessons over the course of the year-long programme. In America a study of 237 second grade children used piano keyboard training and newly designed math software to demonstrate improvement in math skills. The piano group scored 27% higher on proportional math and fractions tests than children that used only the math software.  Data from the National Education Longitudinal Study of 1988 showed that music participants received more academic honors and awards than non-music students, and that the percentage of music participants receiving As and Bs was higher than the percentage of non- participants receiving those grades.  Students who participated in arts programs in selected elementary and middle schools in New York City showed significant increases in self-esteem and thinking skills.
I am sometimes approached by parents who are worried that taking their child out of English or Maths every few weeks on a carousel for their instrumental lesson will have a detrimental effect on their progress.  I am able to reassure them that there is a balancing effect of learning an instrument which is to support these core skills and improve them.  Not only this, but learning an instrument also improves all sorts of other skills and abilities.  Children learning an instrument practice courage, resilience and patience, they learn delayed gratification and the value of daily study in small amounts, their brains become involved in pattern making and matching, they develop abstract language skills in learning to read music notation, and they practice fine and gross motor skills with their bodies.  Most importantly of all, they learn to listen, and not just to hear and process but to finely discern and tune in to fine-grained detail.  Delightfully, many of them develop a joyful and beneficial relationship with their individual teacher which can last a lifetime.
How can you decide on an instrument for your child?  The piano is often a first instrument of choice for many parents, and is a brilliant instrument for children to learn as it helps to get to grips with music theory, but although it seems obvious it is not always the best one to start with.  Some children struggle with reading two lines of music at once.  Children with learning difficulties who may benefit considerably from this different form of learning often find two line or two handed instruments difficult and would benefit from perhaps a brass instrument or at least one with a solo written line rather than chords. Many young children cannot sit still for the required length of time and need an instrument that allows physical movement such as the violin.  Temperament can also play a part – a quiet child may prefer the flute to the saxophone, and a child with a lot of energy may do better with the drums than with the recorder.  Development is important, for instance (with wind instruments) when children may not have all their front teeth or when they may not be big enough to get their arms around a double bass.  There are books available which will help you, for example ‘The Right Instrument for Your Child’ by Arah Ben-Tovim and Douglas Boyd which is available from Amazon and on Kindle. 
Most important of all is your child’s preference.  If they hate the sound of the saxophone they will not commit to learning it.  If they really want to learn the trumpet they may not take kindly to the piano, and “learn the instrument I want you to play and when you pass grade 1 you can do the one you have chosen,” will likely put them off both! Take your children to concerts and have them listen to a range of music styles including classical music on the radio and see what excites them.  Allow them to try out instruments in music shops or get them a trial lesson on an instrument they have been interested in.  The great Hungarian musician Zoltan Kodaly said that ‘Children learn best that which they already know’.  If they have been nagging you for two years to learn the harp take a deep breath and hire one for a month.  If you can’t pull them away from it, get saving.  You may have a harpist in the making.
There are other reasons for children to learn orchestral, jazz or rock instruments other than the piano, and that is the benefit of being able to play them in an ensemble, an activity which is only really available to advanced pianists.  Ensemble playing is a highly social and sociable activity which gets children working together collaboratively rather than competitively and can be begun from the very first term that the child begins the instrument.  One person in an ensemble is only a tiny part of a whole picture which only the whole ensemble can produce.  Concentration, listening skills, forbearance with other children working at more or less advanced levels, timing, co-operation and an understanding of gradual progression are all benefits of involvement in an orchestra, choir or band.  Musically it benefits the child in every possible way, giving them a strong sense of pulse, pitch, dynamics, structure, articulation, tempo, musical style and performance convention and it also makes sense of their instrument in context.  Lastly the buzz of performing in concert with many other musicians is something that can only really be understood once tried – a memorable, exhilarating and uplifting experience.

Thursday, 6 June 2013

Why is education for girls important?

One of the aims of global education is to improve the lives of all who are touched by greater and wider learning. For many this brings the chance of more fulfilled lives and can open opportunity for greater prosperity. In the view of the UN this means improving access to education, world over, for women and girls. This has been the aim of the foundation of the Company of Mary Our Lady for over 400 years, ever since their foundress in Bordeaux in the late sixteenth century realised that to educate society meant educating mothers, sisters and aunts, as that would have the biggest influence over the development of families, and create an educated culture for children to grow into. Opportunities for work come from academic and vocational studies. Appreciation and understanding of others comes from engagement with literature and written materials that extend far beyond personal experience. Moral education is enhanced by understanding the rights of all to take an equal place in society, including women.

The aim of this week’s blog isn’t to repeat a whole set of points regarding single sex education (see my blog from Thursday 17 January 2013) but in considering the rights of women to be educated I thought it worth sharing a further thought from some literature I came across this week: Jacqueline Granleese writes about girls educated in both single sex and co-educational schools in Northern Ireland. She discovered through her research that girls’ attainment and achievement is strongly affected by their self-image. She discovered that within single-sex settings girls’ view of their own abilities and success are influenced by how they behave and attain more than how they look or perceive that they are being viewed, by others, whereas girls in co-ed settings are more likely to base their sense of self on how they look and how their appearance may be judged. Although this seems a small difference, the impact on attainment and studies can be quiet dramatic. Students’ view of themselves quickly extends to their expectations and to their own engagement with the environment in which they are taught. It seems fatuous to think pretty girls, or at least those who seem attractive to certain boys, do better, but that in essence is what girls can quickly come to believe and it deeply affects their own self-esteem and therefore their progress, regardless of their abilities (we are talking about teenagers here…).

Professor Chris Holligan points out that this has a knock on effect to the perception that certain subjects in a co-ed school take on the subconscious subtext that they are for boys (physics and mathematics) or for girls (languages and creative subjects) and become quickly stigmatised. Girls in these settings become wary that they will appear more masculine by choosing technical or science subjects. Dr Leonard Sax also flags up the point that for many adolescents the presence in the classrooms of the opposite sex causes a distraction that makes full attention difficult, especially in view of the idea that a sense of self-worth can be related to physical appearance rather than to academic success.

In the light of the struggle to educate women worldwide, and in order to create more equable societies it seems incongruous that positive discrimination is what is needed here in the UK to enable women to have the equality they require in education settings. However for many, it does seem that positive single sex discrimination is the most effective way to educate young women for the future.  

Thursday, 23 May 2013

What use is a forest school?

It was my privilege last week to spend some time outside with 3 and 4 year old pupils at Notre Dame Forest School. This initiative, guided by Forest School Leader Ms Stephens, and the rest of the Owls Team, allows our BlueBelles Nursery pupils to spend time in the environment learning not only new skills and concepts, but developing their relationship with the world. This chimed with my blog last week about the importance of using guided experiences to allow us to grow as whole people.

The little children I joined were happy, fully engaged, interested, inquisitive and bubbling with enthusiasm. They commandeered me to paint mud onto the trees with them and showed me the bugs they had swept up, gently into cups to examine. I was surprised at their sophistication, gathering tiny fragments from around them to make fairy houses, and their ability to explain what they were doing. I felt a pull from my own happy childhood, where I learned to be creative through a freedom to explore. These children are lucky indeed.

Most children spend a great deal of their educational lives indoors, only being allowed out to ‘play’. This is appropriate if we believe that learning can only take place under certain conditions, if we think that a teacher has to push knowledge into a child in a sterile environment. However, we now understand far more about the growth of children’s brains, and are beginning to understand that intelligence develops through activity, making connections, creative inspiration and rehearsal. Creativity is never nurtured best in confined conditions, and inspiration rarely strikes if prescribed outcomes are valued above great ideas. Connections certainly cannot be made for them, instead of by then, if they are to have real meaning, and it is only possible to rehearse what is already understood. That is not to say that class based learning is outdated, it still plays the major part, and much can be taught and learnt by conventional means, but there is more…..and practical activities such as camping, forest skills, Duke of Edinburgh awards and environmental studies can extend potential by "encouraging and inspiring individuals through positive outdoor experiences" as the Forest Schools do.
In the future school leaders will increasingly accept that creativity is vital to the formation of human beings and to the future of society, and that it is generated not by the training of fixed outcomes but by open ended experiences. None of us can be sure what the future will hold, nor what will happen to the shape of examinations in the next ten years, nor to the world of work or even to society in general, but those children who have developed resilience, interest, inspiration and independence, outside, in the beauty and complexity of creation, will have the advantage over the rest of us.

Now put down this computer and go outside for a walk.